Tasmania rejects The Australian’s misleading claims on trans prison policy

Image of Tasmanian Parliament in the background. Foreground shows the snippet from The Australian's recent story.

Tasmania’s Attorney-General has confirmed the state has not banned trans women from women’s prisons, despite headlines in The Australian suggesting the opposite.

Content warning: This article contains discussions of sexual abuse, transphobia, and suicide.

Equality Tasmania has praised the clarification, saying it affirms more than a decade of evidence-based policy that keeps all prisoners—including trans women—safe.

It comes as other states, including the Northern Territory, face growing criticism for misleading and harmful rhetoric about transgender prisoners.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by QNews (@qnewsmag)

Background: Misleading reporting sparked confusion

Confusion began after The Australian published a report claiming the Tasmanian Government had “banned trans-identifying male prisoners from women’s prisons”.

The story hinged on an exceptional case involving an offender convicted of child abuse whose requests to be housed in the women’s prison had been denied.

Crucially, those denials were made under the state’s existing case-by-case policy, which has been in place since 2009 and allows trans women to be housed in the women’s prison where safe and appropriate.

Advocates described The Australian’s framing as misleading and inflammatory, noting the paper’s long-documented pattern of sensational reporting on transgender issues.

A pattern is so concerning and obvious, it was previously reprimanded by the Australian Press Council for breaching fairness and accuracy standards.

TAS Government rejects claims of a trans ban

A new report in The Mercury quotes Attorney-General Guy Barnett, who has “rejected claims the government had banned transgender inmates from serving time in women’s prisons.”

Barnett said current guidelines still apply, affirming the rights of “transgender, transsexual and intersex prisoners to be housed in a correctional facility appropriate to their gender identification.”

Equality Tasmania welcomed the clarification.

Trans advocate Martine Delaney praised the government for not walking back long-standing policy because of “an exceptional case reported wrongly in one newspaper”.

Delaney emphasised that the real safety risk is trans women being forced into men’s facilities, citing the case of Marjorie Harwood, a trans woman who was gang-raped when wrongly held in a male prison. Harwood later died after refusing treatment to avoid being returned to the men’s unit.

Equality Tasmania’s Rodney Croome said the government’s response showed it was prioritising “the needs of vulnerable Tasmanians” despite increasing interstate attacks on inclusive policies.

The State Government is also developing a new Gender Oversight Panel to prevent future misplacements like Harwood’s.

Image of Guy Barnett with a snippet from the Mercury overlayed
Images: Facebook / The Mercury

Similar misinformation fuelling harmful debates in the NT

Tasmania’s clarity comes as other jurisdictions face rising pressure and misinformation about transgender prisoners, particularly in the Northern Territory.

NT Chief Minister Lia Finocchiaro recently suggested banning trans women from female jails, prompting strong criticism from advocates, legal experts and the NT Anti-Discrimination Commissioner.

Incarcerated trans women in the NT have reported “homophobic” and violent treatment in men’s units. Advocates warn they are far more likely to be victims than perpetrators.

NT Anti-Discrimination Commissioner Jeswynn Yogaratnam’s statement labelled the Chief Minister’s comments as “alarmist” and  “unsupported by evidence from the NT”.

“[The comments] risk inflaming prejudice and hostility toward trans Territorians.

“They also fail to acknowledge the significant, long-documented safety risks faced by transgender prisoners in men’s units at NT correctional facilities.”

Advocates continue to reiterate that these debates are being driven not by evidence, but by misinformation and a growing national pattern of using trans prisoners as a political wedge despite years of data showing trans women are overwhelmingly the ones most at risk.

If you need someone to talk to, help is available from QLife on 1800 184 527 or at QLife.org.au. Other services you can call: Lifeline 13 11 14. Kids Helpline 1800 55 1800. Beyondblue 1300 22 4636.

For the latest LGBTIQA+ Sister Girl and Brother Boy news, entertainment, and community stories in Australia, visit qnews.com.au. Find us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and YouTube.

QNews, Brisbane Gay, App, Gay App, LGBTI, LGBTI News, Gay Australia

Get the best of what’s queer.

About The Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *