Alan Turing’s life was defined by two things: his brilliance and by his persecution for being gay.
Now, a debut novel by QBD Books CEO Nick Croydon has rewritten him as straight, and readers are furious.
Alan Turing, the war hero and computer pioneer who was persecuted for being gay, has been reimagined in a new novel by QBD Books CEO Nick Croydon.
This significant change has sparked backlash from readers who say the book erases a core part of his identity.
Why Alan Turing’s story matters
Alan Turing (1912–1954) was a British mathematician and pioneering computer scientist. His work at Bletchley Park during World War II helped crack the Nazi Enigma code, potentially shortening the war by years and saving millions of lives.
After the war, Turing was prosecuted under Britain’s laws against homosexuality. He was forced to undergo chemical castration and stripped of his security clearance before dying by suicide in 1954.
The UK government issued a posthumous apology in 2009. In 2013 he received a royal pardon for his “crime” of being gay.
The 2017 “Alan Turing Law” pardoned other men convicted under historical anti-gay laws.
An alternate history with a secret child
The Turing Protocol follows Turing after his real-life success in cracking Nazi Germany’s Enigma code.
But, in the novel’s alternate history, Turing creates a time-travel machine and secretly fathers a child with a woman named Joan.
The story then spans decades through the fictional Turing family as the device changes the course of events across history.
In real life, Joan Clarke was someone who worked with Turing at Bletchley Park. The pair secretly got engaged, but Turing revealed he was gay, called off the engagement, and they remained friends.

An insult to Turing’s memory
The backlash has been swift, with many readers criticising the book for altering Turing’s sexuality online.
“Nick has taken the story of someone who was only pardoned in 2013 for his ‘crime’ of being homosexual and spun it for his own… story,” one wrote on Goodreads. “He deserves a lot better than this.”
Another described the portrayal as “literally an attack on his memory” and said the reimagined cause of his death in the novel — shifting it from the real-life circumstances of homophobia and chemical castration to a fictional “communist murder” — was “an insult to Turing’s memory.”
“The way his death is treated is completely out of line,” the reviewer writes.
“Fictionalising what was a very horrific homophobia-fuelled death and turning it into a communist murder that USED this narrative to cover-up said murder is diabolical.
“Its an insult to Turing’s memory and the societal prejudice he had to endure and the homophobia that continues to talk the lives of queer people in the twenty-first century.
“I sincerely hope no members of the Turing family stumble across this book because they do not deserve that.”
The backlash has continued to trickle through in reviews, with another person adding:
“What is wrong with Croydon to… have chosen a prominent LGBTQIA+ figure and make him secretly straight.”
A wider climate of historical erasure
Queer erasure in history is not new by any means, but the controversy comes as political actors, like Trump, increasingly interfere with how history is told.
This week, US President Donald Trump began a sweeping review of the Smithsonian Institution’s museums. He has directed them to “begin implementing content corrections… replacing divisive or ideologically driven language with unifying, historically accurate, and constructive descriptions.”
Among the museums targeted in the first phase are:
- National Museum of American History.
- The National Museum of African American History and Culture.
- The National Museum of the American Indian.
For the latest LGBTIQA+ Sister Girl and Brother Boy news, entertainment, and community stories in Australia, visit qnews.com.au. Find us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and YouTube.









Thanks for covering this. What’s also appalling is how QBD has:
– not made it clear they’re recommending a book by their CEO
– seemingly flagged negative reviews on Goodreads as ‘suspicious’ to have them removed. Multiple posters complained and were able to repost their reviews. They’re livid. And you don’t want to piss off the Goodreads community!
– further attempted to game Goodreads by having brand-new users post glowing but generic reviews. One even mentions the pleasant QBD shopping experience!
– issued a press release (see the Daily Mail’s article today) in which QBD – not the author, not the publisher – defend this rewriting of history as somehow respectful and defend using employees to write reviews… while still making no mention of the fact that the author is the CEO!
All of which begs the question: how did this sloppily written and offensive ‘thriller’ not only get published (given straight white men supposedly are dead to publishers) but get so heavily promoted? Was it a quid pro quo for shelf space?
– Given there’s supposedly a sequel in the works (!), and that the book has been sold internationally, I imagine the Turing family, and UK historians, will have strong views.