Opinion: Labor’s election triumph, the Greens’ struggle, and the questions ahead

Image of Anthony Albanese on stage with son and Fiancé after winning election.

The Liberal Party has suffered a major defeat this election, and the brand of Trump-style, culture war politics they’ve been dabbling in has been firmly rejected at the ballot box.

That’s something to note. But I don’t think we can all exhale just yet.

Because while the end of fear-driven campaigning is welcome, Labor’s likely majority raises its own set of concerns.

Democracy requires diversity.

Power without balance rarely leads to accountability, and with little resistance expected in the lower house, all eyes now turn to how this government will actually deliver on the promises it’s made.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by QNews (@qnewsmag)

I’ll admit, a Labor landslide scares me a little

Call me skeptical but I wasn’t immediately jumping for joy when I saw how much of a majority Labor is expected to have.

Here’s the problem: after this election, Labor likely has the numbers in the Lower House to do just about anything they want there, and that’s not necessarily a good thing.

I was hoping for a more diverse landscape in the House of Reps, where there were more left-leaning independents and Greens members to keep Labor in check.

Instead, we’re looking at a situation that could become dangerous.

Some voters are happy that Labor might finally be able to pass policies that were previously blocked by crossbenchers, and I’ll admit this could bring about some positive change.

But majority rule doesn’t guarantee progressive outcomes, or outcomes at all. What it guarantees is less friction. Whether that leads to actual reform remains to be seen.

Labor talks a big game. They hold inquiries, commission reports, run consultations and make promises. But we don’t always see the necessary action.

For example, Labor previously promised to appoint an LGBTIQA+ Human Rights Commissioner. Where is that commissioner now? Hint: there isn’t one.

One can only hope that with a diverse Senate, we will see the pressure needed to keep Labor in check.

This election’s rejection of the right is still a win

Despite my obvious cynicism and suspicions, it would be wrong for me not to acknowledge that booting out Dutton in the way we did is a huge win.

The Liberal Party’s performance during their election campaign was an outright failure. Their platform of division, control, and culture wars was rejected decisively and that is spectacular.

Australians showed they’re not interested in importing Trumpian politics, thank god.

But this wasn’t exactly a vote of confidence in Labor either, it was a vote against something far worse.

What remains to be seen is whether the opposition learns anything from this.

If the Liberals want to be relevant, they need to rethink who they are and who they serve, not just dial up the dog-whistles and hope for a different result.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Adam Bandt (@adambandt)

The Greens messaging didn’t always hit

The Greens recorded their highest national vote ever, though it hasn’t translated into lower house wins.

Some of that is structural. Preferential voting. Risk-averse electorates. Once-Liberal voters were voting for Labor, current Liberal voters were preferencing Labor above Greens. This all comes into play.

But part of it, from my perspective, is messaging.

The Greens’ campaign felt disconnected at times. In some places, it landed. In others, it came off as, frankly, isolating.

The “just vote Greens or you’re sh*t” rhetoric might rally the base, but it sometimes alienates the very people they need to persuade.

I say this as someone who’s worked with the Greens before and supported their policies — I’m not anti-Greens.

But their campaigning doesn’t always leave space for discussion and healthy diversity. If a person asked a question without being 100% green, despite being left-leaning, they’d be ostracised by many.

I truly despised constantly being met with the “Greens aren’t perfect but we can’t harm their campaign or Liberals may win so let’s just stay silent” energy. There should be policy conversations, openness for diverse perspectives, room for accountability. This goes for all parties.

I’m sure if I felt this way, the unsure voters must have felt even more isolated from the Greens.

There’s a lesson here, as there is on every side, and I hope they take it seriously.

The to-do list is long

We’ve had reviews into anti-discrimination. Commitments to First Nations justice post-Voice. Climate targets. Aged care reform recommendations. Cost of living promises.

All of it now needs to move beyond announcements and into implementation.

So, where does that leave us?

Labor has the numbers. The Senate has some diversity. The Liberals are in crisis. The Greens are recalibrating.

None of that guarantees progress.

What comes next will depend on how loud we stay, how much pressure we apply, and how hard we push. Especially on the issues that matter most to our communities.

We’ve seen what inaction looks like. Let’s not let them slip back into it.

Election results so far

For those who want an update, here is a break down of the results at this stage:

As of Sunday morning, the Australian Electoral Commission has counted 71.1% of votes. Not much more is expected today as the AEC focuses on sorting and transporting, but here’s the current lower house breakdown:

Labor: 85 seats
Liberal: 37 seats
Independents: 7 seats
Greens: 0 seats

In the Senate, we’re seeing a more diverse outcome:

Labor: 28 seats (12 continuing, 12 won, 4 likely)
Coalition: 26 seats (14 continuing, 6 won, 6 likely)
Greens: 11 seats (5 continuing, 4 won, 2 likely)

For the latest LGBTIQA+, Sister Girl and Brother Boy news, entertainment, community stories in Australia, visit qnews.com.au. Find us on Facebook, X, Instagram and YouTube.

QNews, Brisbane Gay, App, Gay App, LGBTI, LGBTI News, Gay Australia

Get the best of what’s queer.

About The Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *