Mistrial declared in death of gay US college student

University of Mississippi

The prosecution of the alleged killer of a 20-year-old American student has collapsed after jurors were unable to reach a verdict.

Jimmy “Jay “ Lee has been missing from Oxford, Mississippi, since July of 2022 and has not contacted friends or family or made any financial transactions or posted on social media since then.

Police arrested 24-year-old Sheldon “Timothy” Herrington Jr two weeks after Lee’s disappearance and subsequently charged him with capital murder.

Investigators obtained explicit messages between the two men, establishing that they had a sexual history.

Lee was a prominent LGBTQIA+ member of the University of Mississippi community who performed as a drag queen at local venues, and had recently started a masters degree.

Herrington was also a graduate of the University of Mississippi, but was not out.

Prosecutors allege that the pair had previously met for sex at Herrington’s apartment but things went awry, with Lee ending the encounter and leaving early.

Harrington is alleged to have searched online for information on how long it takes to strangle a person and was caught on security camera purchasing duct tape on the same day as Lee’s disappearance.

The last message Lee sent from his phone was to Herrington from a spot near the apartment where they had previously met.

That same morning, Herrington was caught on camera running out of the parking lot where Lee’s car was found abandoned.

Herrington’s defence attorney told the jury that prosecutors could not prove Lee had been killed without a body. However a previous court hearing had already declared him dead.

Despite that, and after hearing eight days of arguments and testimony and nine hours of deliberation, the jurors were unable to reach a verdict.

The jury twice communicated to Circuit Judge Kelly Luther that they were deadlocked, so they were told that they could also consider the lesser charges of first-degree murder, second degree murder, or manslaughter.

However when the jury announced they were deadlocked a third time, Justice Luther dismissed the case.

Both Herrington and Lee’s families were present in the court and were instructed to leave separately.

Justice Luther will now consult with prosecutors and Herrington’s defence team about setting up another trial.

For the latest LGBTIQA+ Sister Girl and Brother Boy news, entertainment, community stories in Australia, visit qnews.com.au. Check out our latest magazines or find us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and YouTube.

QNews, Brisbane Gay, App, Gay App, LGBTI, LGBTI News, Gay Australia

Get the best of what’s queer.

About The Author

3 thoughts on “Mistrial declared in death of gay US college student”

  1. Personally I just don’t think it’s appropriate to report on this story. This could potentially really whip up homophobia, fear and hatred towards gay men & transgender individuals – in the age of Trump within America. Americans people are just very immature and silly!

    1. LGBT USA Justice

      Reporting on this case serves to highlight critical issues such as justice for LGBTQIA+ individuals, systemic biases, and the dangers they continue to face. We can’t simply sweep stuff like this under the carpet.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *