Most of what we know of LGBTIQ Australians in the colonial era comes from court and prison records. Australia’s earliest known gay love letter is no different. Indeed, it is the letter of a convict to the person he loved most — a man he knew he would never see again.
Denis Prendergast (or Pendergast) arrived in Australia as a convict in 1838. He disembarked in Van Diemen’s Land but sometime later ended up on Norfolk Island. That exquisitely beautiful but notorious island housed the men colonial administrators judged “the worst description of convicts.” Norfolk Island gained a reputation as the cruellest of all Australian penal colonies.
In 1846, a new administrator took away one of the few ‘luxuries’ the inmates enjoyed — personal billies and kettles used to cook their meals. Determined to crack down on even the smallest liberties allowed the convicts by the previous administrator, the petty tyrant decreed that in future all meals would be cooked in bulk.
Some convicts decided they’d had enough.
Nearly a decade before, William Westwood received a sentence of transportation to New South Wales for stealing a coat. Assigned as a servant on a station, he attempted to escape because of mistreatment by an overseer. For that, he received 50 lashes. The embittered convict escaped again for a life of bushranging.
Known as the ‘gentleman bushranger’ for his courtesy and refusal to hurt anyone, William went by the bushranging alias of Jackey Jackey. Never rude to women, he beat up and threatened to kill a fellow bushranger who raped a female victim.
Captured a number of times, William received 50 to 100 lashes with every new term of imprisonment. But that never dissuaded him from escape. Once, he and two other prisoners absconded from Port Arthur. Located on a peninsula, only a 30-metre-wide isthmus connected the prison to the mainland. Soldiers guarded that passage along with half-starved dogs. William and two other convicts decided to escape by swimming to the mainland. Only William made it. The other two fell victim to shark attack.
Eventually, the gentleman bushranger found himself sentenced to Norfolk Island.
By 1946, he wearied of a life of rigid discipline and harsh punishment. The confiscation of the cooking pots proved the last straw. He addressed his fellow prisoners.
“I’ve made up my mind to bear this oppression no longer. But, remember, I’m going to the gallows. If any man funks, let him stand out. Those who want to follow me — come on!”
1,600 convicts joined William in the riot. An overseer and three constables were killed. However, when confronted by a line of soldiers with muskets at the ready, the convicts surrendered.
William and eleven other prominent leaders of the rebellion were sentenced to hang. Among them, Denis Prendergast. After the mass execution, the men’s bodies were dumped in a pit outside the cemetery.
Norfolk Island’s reputation
Other than beauty and cruelty, Norfolk Island bore a reputation for one other thing…
‘Crimes’ that the Catholic Vicar-General of the colonies told an inquiry “would make your blood to freeze and your hair to rise erect in horror.”
300 convicts in same-sex ‘marriages’
The Vicar-General claimed up to two-thirds of the island population indulged in same-sex ‘crimes’. In the year of the Cooking Pot Riot, a visiting magistrate reported that as many as 300 of the convicts on the island lived together as ‘man and wife’.
We don’t know if homosexuality played any role in the Cooking Pot Riot. But we do know at least one of the ring-leaders was gay.
Because on the eve of his execution, Denis Prendergast penned a letter that survived to become Australia’s earliest known gay love letter.
I hope you won’t forget me when I am far away and all my bones is moldered away. I have not closed an eye since I lost sight of you. Your precious sight was always a welcome and loving charming spectacle.
I value Death nothing but it is in leaving you my dear behind and no one to look after you…
The only thing that grieves me love is when I think of the pleasant nights we have had together.
I hope you won’t fall in love with no other man when I am dead and I remain your True and loving affectionate Lover.
For the latest lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex and queer (LGBTIQ) news in Australia, visit qnews.com.au. Check out our latest magazines or find us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and YouTube.