Geelong Rainbow condemns article sensationalising ‘chest feeding’

A modern glass and wood office building with a blue sky overhead. Over this is a circular graphic with text and a rainbow umbrella icon at the top.

Geelong Rainbow Inc has released a statement condemning the Geelong Advertiser for an article it says intends “to stir up anger against the transgender community“.

The article, titled “Geelong council rebrands breastfeeding rooms ‘chest feeding’”, was originally published by the News Corp masthead on 15 May. It covers the Geelong council’s choice to update terminology used in their enterprise agreement, now referring to a “breast/chest feeding” room at their Wurriki Nyal Civic Precinct headquarters in the new version of the agreement.

It featured multiple quotes from Colleen Harkin from Institute of Public Affairs, a nonprofit the writer Lucy Crock calls a “right-wing think tank”, and one quote from Geelong Rainbow’s secretary, Ruthe Geller.

In their media release, Geelong Rainbow criticise the article’s bias towards Harkin’s quotes, writing: “We believed the article would be comprised of neutral coverage about the Geelong council renaming its breastfeeding room to ‘chest feeding room.’ Instead, the article turned out to be, in our opinion, an overblown, politically charged hit piece created with the intention to stir up anger against the transgender community.”

Related content:

‘Exaggerates a non-issue’

In their statement, Geelong Rainbow assert that the harm in the article stems not only from its platforming of Harkin, but the way it “exaggerates a non-issue”.

In the Advertiser‘s article from City of Greater Geelong acting executive director of corporate services Monica Thomson expressly says that the updated terminology regarding the room in question only appears in the council’s enterprise agreement — nowhere else. “There is no signage stating the name of the room, nor is it titled ‘breast/chest feeding room’,” she said. “We are committed to inclusion, diversity and equity, including the use of inclusive and gender-neutral language in documentation like our enterprise agreement.”

However, the article then goes on to quote Harkin saying that “Public institutions should prioritise clarity and common sense over activist language trends” and “Local government should focus on rates, roads and rubbish, not rewriting basic biology”.

Geelong Rainbow question the inclusion of Harkin as a commenter on the story. “According to her biography on the IPA’s website, Harkin’s education and career experience is related to teaching and education, so it is unknown why she was approached for comment on a situation that has nothing to do with the education system,” their statement reads.

Diptych; on the left is a segment of a media release from Geelong Rainbow Inc expressing disappointment with Geelong Advertiser. On the right, A person breastfeeding a baby in front of a building with columns. The text reads 'Ideological jargon': Row over 'chest feeding' room.
Geelong Rainbow criticised the Geelong Advertiser’s article (pictured right) in a statement posted to social media (pictured left). / Instagram and Facebook

Creating fear and outrage about the transgender community leads to harm

Geelong Rainbow emphasise the non-issue of the story at large, noting that its fear-mongering about inclusivity can lead to harm. “‘Chest feeding’ only appears in internal council documents, and there appear to be no intentions to change the name of any breastfeeding rooms. We believe that the article was created to primarily stoke outrage among readers, to the detriment of the transgender community,” they write.

“We live in a time where transgender people are still being assaulted and murdered at disproportionate rates,” they continue, citing the recent murder of transgender University of Washington student Juniper Blessing. “There is no way to sugar coat it: Creating fear and outrage about the transgender community leads to harm”.

The statement concludes by saying Geelong Rainbow “stand wholeheartedly by Ruthe’s comment” in the original article, and go on to quote it in full, rather than the condensed version included in the Advertiser‘s article.

“The reframing of ‘breast-feeding’ facilities to ‘chest-feeding’ facilities is not only a greatly appreciated validation that transmasculine and nonbinary parents are valued as they are, but is even more vitally a statement that all nursing parents are welcome and safe in these facilities,” Geller says. “This means that, even in this small way, more parents are able to comfortably spend their day-to-day focused on their families, resting assured that they are all supported by Geelong’s uplifting community.”

For the latest LGBTQIA+ Sister Girl and Brother Boy news, entertainment, and community stories in Australia, visit qnews.com.au. Find us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and YouTube.

QNews, Brisbane Gay, App, Gay App, LGBTI, LGBTI News, Gay Australia

Get the best of what’s queer.

About The Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *