AFL Appeals Board justification for homophobia disappointing, dangerous and disgusting

Former players Kate McCarthy, Mitch Brown, Leigh Ryswyk and the AFL itself are speaking out about the Appeals Board’s decision to reduce St Kilda player Lance Collard’s suspension for a homophobic slur, especially the statement they used to announce it.

This is the second time in three seasons Collard has been found guilty of using homophobic language in a VFL match.

The first time in 2024, the 21-year-old received a six-game ban.

Last week, the AFL Disciplinary Tribunal handed down a nine-week suspension; this week, the Appeals Board reduced the sentence to four weeks, two of which have been suspended.

Collard’s charge of conduct unbecoming was upheld.

The Board said they found the original suspension to be “manifestly excessive” given Collard’s age, Indigenous heritage and difficult background.

When compared to Collard’s previous use of a homophobic slur, they said the victim was not personally offended, and the context of the altercation leading up to the slur was a deciding factor.

Image: AFL.com.au

But one sentence in the Appeals Board’s statement has sent ripples through all levels of our national sport. And people are not happy.

“It is commonplace that players can employ language from time to time which is racist, sexist or homophobic whilst on the field,” they said.

As the news continued to circulate Friday morning, and people shared their outrage online, former AFLW star-turned-commentator Kate McCarthy was the first to speak out, saying she was “speechless”.

‘This is disgusting’

“Not only has he re-offended,” McCarthy said on Instagram, “But he’s actually got less of a suspension this time.”

McCarthy echoed and gave voice to what so many people were thinking about the Appeal Boards statement.

“I had to check that this was an official source,” she said, “It is commonplace that players can employ language from time to time which is racist.”

“So not only homophobia, we’re happy for racism, we’re happy for sexism, and we’re happy for homophobia just from time to time on the field, and it’s commonplace, guys, it’s all good.”

“What the hell, like? I have no way to describe this. It’s actually baffling.

“So much for every policy in the AFL saying that there’s zero tolerance, there’s zero tolerance for racism, there’s zero tolerance for sexism, there’s zero tolerance for homophobia.

“No, not according to the appeals board. You know it’s commonplace. You know you can do it from time to time.

“This decision and this explanation of this decision goes against everything that the AFL has claimed to stand for. This is disgusting.”

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Kate McCarthy (@kate.mac.9)

Former St Kilda midfielder Luke Ball told ABC Sport Daily that he “can’t get my head around the language that the appeals board have used.”

“To me, it’s almost like they’ve dusted off a book from the 1990’s or 1980’s with some of their reasoning and their language as to an explanation to why they’ve reduced the penalty so heavily. To say that these things happen on a footy field from time to time … I thought we’d well and truly moved past that.”

“I think ‘commonplace’ is incorrect,” he said, “I’d be waiting for an AFL response on this.”

‘Respect and inclusion are not optional in our game’

AFL CEO Andrew Dillon came out swinging on Friday afternoon, criticising the Appeals Board.

“Let me be clear: homophobia has no place in Australian football. Not at any level. Not under any circumstances,” he said.

“The AFL specifically rejects the Appeals Board’s reasoning, which stated, ‘it is commonplace that players can employ language from time to time which is racist, sexist or homophobic whilst on the field’.”

“The AFL strongly rejects the statement not only that such language is commonplace, but also any implication that may be a factor in determining the severity of the sanction.

“We will not accept, excuse or normalise behaviour and language that demeans, discriminates or vilifies people based on who they are.

Related content

“We acknowledge there are always broader considerations in these matters, and they must be handled with care. But they do not override the responsibility everyone has to meet the standards of the game.

“We are clear on where we stand. Respect and inclusion are not optional in our game – they are fundamental.”

Openly bisexual former AFL player Mitch Brown said the appeal board’s statement shows how “one decision can undo the tireless and gruelling advocacy of hundreds of people, over many years, to make the sport a safer and more inclusive place.”

‘It is not only disappointing, but dangerous’

“There is so much wrong with this statement,” Brown posted on Friday, “It is not only disappointing, but dangerous.”

“There is something sickly satisfying about this as someone who has been told repeatedly over the years – and especially in the six months since I chose to come out last year – that there is no homophobia problem within the AFL.”

“It’s almost refreshing to have the appeal board say it so plainly – homophobia (and sexism and racism) – are inherent and acceptable parts of our game from time to time.”

Brown said he had gotten to know many people in the AFL since coming out, “who care deeply and passionately about eradicating these behaviours from the sport and making it safe and inclusive for all.”

“I can’t imagine their despair today, as it feels like years and years of tireless advocacy has been reversed overnight.”

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Mitch Brown (@mitchbrownie)

Brown said the appeals board’s reasoning that Frankston player Darby Hipwell wasn’t offended by the comment “is ludicrous”.

“It implies that we can use homophobic slurs whenever we like, as long as it’s not directed at a queer person,” he said

“This is deeply dangerous and problematic. Slurs and hate speech are harmful to anyone who hears them, whether they were the intended recipient or not.”

“The queer community suffers every time these incidents happen.

“In particular, the increase in homophobia both online and at games after these incidents and their surrounding media attention is deeply unsettling and traumatising for many of us within the community.

“This is why the AFL has been right in taking such a strong stance to eradicate homophobia, sexism and racism from the game – until now.”

Leadership should lift standards, not lower them

Former AFL player Leigh Ryswyk, who came out publicly as gay this year, said, “footy being tough can never justify language that demeans or excludes.”

“The intensity of sport does not excuse homophobia, sexism or racism,” he said in an online statement.

“Leadership in challenging environments should lift standards, not lower them.”

Ryswyk reinforced the “strong and clear responses” of the AFL rejecting the appeals board’s reasoning and “their commitment to stating that homophobia has no place in Australian football.”

“Those statements reinforce values that so many people have worked hard to embed in the game.”

“Progress and inclusion are not always straightforward, but moments like these remind us why accountability, leadership and clear standards are essential.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Leigh Ryswyk (@ryswyk32)

“Football holds enormous cultural power…the work towards inclusive and respectful footy is far from over, that work deserves to be strengthened and not set back.

“Let’s not let this take us back from what we’ve already been doing and what people in our community are doing, and let’s really move forward.

“It’s a great opportunity right now for everyone to set a standard and live by that.”

For the latest LGBTIQA+ Sister Girl and Brother Boy news, entertainment, and community stories in Australia, visit qnews.com.au. Find us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and YouTube.

QNews, Brisbane Gay, App, Gay App, LGBTI, LGBTI News, Gay Australia

Get the best of what’s queer.

About The Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *